Best Sellers
What Our Customers Say
I bought these shoes for my husband. He loves them and got so many compliments when he wore them on Sunday. They were the brown with black suede trim. He also said they were very comfortable. The price was good. The service was good. We received them within a week or two. Overall, very happy. I would recommend to others.Marjorie Barnes
I was hesitant to buy a nice pair of shoes on-line. After reading many reviews and seeing the presence of these shoes on-line, I took a chance and ordered a pair. I have had them for a few weeks now and I am so HAPPY AND PLEASED with the comfort, quality and the nice style of the shoes.Topo Padilla
I love these shoes. They are very comfortable, especially with the gel insoles I put in. I got two pairs and the price was great. They look really nice.David Mundy
"The most comfortable shoes I’ve ever owned. I stand up for 8 hours at trade shows and can’t feel any fatigue. Unbelievable low price too."Jacques
My husband loves these shoes and they look so good!!Sandy
No complaints here. Nice casual dress shoe that is lightweight and looks great to me. Feels like wearing a running shoe. Shipping time was good and priced lower than a good pair of dress or running shoes.M Rivera
Have ordered 3 sets of shoes. They look and feel great! I have some nerve damage, so any type of heel is dangerous for me while walking, these shoes solved that and still look fine with my dress slacks and casual suit. Plus I need extra wide. Truly outstanding.C Marcus
Purchase two pairs of shoes from Gatsby. The feel and comfort of these shoes is just outstanding. These are all day wearable shoes.James Dunn
Thus far, after one week of wearing the shoes frequently, I am very satisfied with the performance of the shoes. They are light weight and very comfortable. If they hold up over the long term I am certain I will be a long term customer.Steve Cokonougher
As Seen In
Fast Shipping
Get your order lightning fast with easy phone tracking.
Happy Customers
Over 1,000,000 pairs sold with trusted 5-star reviews.
Expert Craftsmanship
Handcrafted by shoemakers using premium leather daily.
30-Day Guarantee
Enjoy worry-free returns and exchanges within 30 days.
Where Style Meets Comfort
At Gatsby, we believe that style shouldn't hurt. We started Gatsby because we were tired of sacrificing comfort for aesthetics — especially when it came to dress shoes. Wide feet? Forget it. Long days on your feet? You were expected to suffer through them. That didn’t sit right with us.
Gatsby Formals
Sharp, handcrafted leather shoes for weddings, meetings, and elevated occasions.
Explore the CollectionGatsby Casuals
Effortless style meets sneaker-level comfort — perfect for everyday wear.
Discover Casual Comfort
